The 2 Best Closed Toe Hiking Sandals of 2025, Reviewed and Compare

If you’re passionate about summer adventures on both the beach and the trails, finding the perfect pair of closed-toe hiking sandals is essential. Leading footwear brands like KEEN, Teva, and Hoka have crafted exceptional designs that prioritize comfort, support, and protection, ensuring your feet are well-equipped for any outdoor challenge.

Whether you enjoy thrilling trail excursions or leisurely water sports, having the right hiking-ready sandals serves as a fantastic alternative to traditional hiking shoes—especially in hot or wet conditions. These sandals are not only lightweight and breathable but also offer waterproof capabilities and a range of features that enhance your hiking experience.

With a vast selection of options on the market, choosing the right pair can feel overwhelming. To simplify your decision-making process, we’ve conducted thorough lab testing and analyzed over 20+ data points to present you with the 2 Best Closed Toe Hiking Sandals available. Our data-driven approach highlights top performers based on rigorous evaluations, so you can confidently select the ideal sandals for your next summer adventure.

KEEN Newport H2

Pros

  • Versatile for various hikes
  • Exceptionally plush
  • Incredible grip level
  • Stable and supportive
  • Day-one comfort
  • Easy and fast to lace up
  • Quick-drying
  • Stink-proof

Cons

  • Heavier than average
  • Traps debris

Key Features

  • Water-Resistant: Quick-dry washable synthetic straps and lining ensure active use in and out of the water all summer long.
  • Support & Comfort: Featuring a lace lock bungee capture system for a secure fit, these sandals provide quick on and off access, complemented by shock-absorbing support for enhanced cushioning.
  • Traction & Protection: Equipped with multi-directional lugs and siping channels, they offer superior grip on slippery terrains, while non-marking rubber outsoles leave no imprints indoors or on boats. The iconic toe bumper adds an extra layer of safety against injury.
  • Fit & Insole: Designed with KEEN's original fit, they provide ample space across the forefoot, allowing toes to spread out comfortably. A non-removable footbed with added arch support ensures all-day comfort.
  • Care Tips: The KEEN water sandals are machine washable; just use a small amount of detergent on a gentle cycle and air dry away from heat to keep them fresh and ready for your next adventure.

Specifications

  • Origin: Imported
  • Sole Material: Rubber
  • Outer Material: Synthetic
  • Inner Material: Mesh

The KEEN Newport H2 is a top choice for those seeking a closed-toe hiking sandal that offers significant stability and protection. It excels in both lab tests and real-world hiking conditions, providing excellent traction while keeping toes safe from sharp objects.

This sandal prioritizes protection, featuring a rubber-coated toe cap and a measured stack height of 29.4 mm at the heel. This thickness is 6.7 mm greater than the average, delivering notable defense against sharp rocks encountered on trails.

In our stability assessments, the KEEN Newport H2 demonstrated impressive results. Its platform width contributes to this stability, with measurements of 121.1 mm at the forefoot and 88.8 mm at the heel, making it wider than many winter hiking boots and exceeding the average widths for hiking sandals by 4.2 mm and 3.6 mm, respectively.

We confidently navigated various terrains, including wet rock and dry gravel, owing to the sandal's effective lug design. With a lug depth of 4.1 mm, which closely aligns with the 4.3 mm average for hiking shoes, the Newport H2 provides reliable grip on diverse surfaces.

However, flexibility is a drawback of this model. During lab testing, we found that bending the sandal to 30° required 14.8N, significantly more than the average of 9.0N for hiking sandals. Consequently, hikers who prefer a more flexible footwear option may want to consider alternatives.

KEEN Newport

Pros

  • Comfortable hiking sandal
  • Durable construction
  • Well-cushioned platform
  • Wide and stable
  • OK for both hot and cold weather
  • Effective traction on various surfaces
  • Zero break-in period

Cons

  • Too heavy
  • Largely inflexible structure

Key Features

  • Water-Resistant: Quick-dry washable synthetic straps and lining ensure active use in and out of the water all summer long.
  • Support & Comfort: Featuring a lace lock bungee capture system for a secure fit, these sandals provide quick on and off access, complemented by shock-absorbing support for enhanced cushioning.
  • Traction & Protection: Equipped with multi-directional lugs and siping channels, they offer superior grip on slippery terrains, while non-marking rubber outsoles leave no imprints indoors or on boats. The iconic toe bumper adds an extra layer of safety against injury.
  • Fit & Insole: Designed with KEEN's original fit, they provide ample space across the forefoot, allowing toes to spread out comfortably. A non-removable footbed with added arch support ensures all-day comfort.
  • Care Tips: The KEEN water sandals are machine washable; just use a small amount of detergent on a gentle cycle and air dry away from heat to keep them fresh and ready for your next adventure.

Specifications

  • Origin: Imported
  • Sole Material: Rubber
  • Outer Material: Synthetic
  • Inner Material: Mesh

The KEEN Newport is an ideal choice for those seeking a sandal that combines the comfort of a shoe with the breathability of a sandal, making it well-suited for full-day hikes. This ultra-protective option offers significant toe box space, earning it recognition as one of the most comfortable closed-toe hiking sandals available.

During our test hikes and lab evaluations, we noted that the footbed of the KEEN Newport is notably robust, featuring an average heel stack height of 27 mm and a forefoot stack of 17.7 mm, which is only 0.9 mm below average. This ample stack height is complemented by a soft midsole, which we measured to have a durometer rating of 22.4 HA, significantly softer than the average of 27 HA. As a result, the sandal provides both protection akin to hiking shoes and the cushioning expected from a quality sandal.

The closed toe design contributes significantly to the shoe-like feel of the KEEN Newport. It effectively withstands bumps and scuffs during hikes, safeguarding the toes from painful impacts. This durability was verified through a Dremel test, where after 12 seconds at 5K RPM and 3.2N, the rubber toe cap showed minimal damage, receiving a score of 5/5 for durability.

Comfortably spacious, the KEEN Newport offers generous room around the toes. The widest part of the sandal measures in line with the average at 102.2 mm, while the area around the big toe boasts a width of 95.9 mm. For context, standard hiking shoes typically measure an average of 81.6 mm around the big toe, indicating that this sandal does not compromise on space.

However, it is important to note that the sturdy construction of the KEEN Newport results in increased weight, measuring 31% heavier than the average for hiking sandals. Hikers seeking a lighter alternative might consider options like the Teva Hurricane Drift.

2 Best Closed Toe Hiking Sandals – Price, Ratings, Reviews & Sales Insights

KEEN Newport H2 Hoka Hopara 2 KEEN Newport
Best Overall Shock absorption Comfort
Price $130 $135 $120
Trail terrain Moderate Light Light
Weight lab Weight brand 13.4 oz / 381g 11.6 oz / 329g 14.6 oz / 414g
Use Day Hiking Day Hiking Light Hiking
Construction Closed toe Closed toe Closed toe
Drop lab 11.0 mm 3.2 mm 9.3 mm
Size Slightly small True to size True to size
Midsole softness Balanced Firm Balanced
Stiffness Stiff Moderate Stiff
Outsole hardness Hard Average Average
Outsole durability - Good Good
Outsole thickness Average Average Average
Lug depth 4.1 mm 3.0 mm 3.1 mm
Heel stack lab 29.4 mm 26.2 mm 27.0 mm
Forefoot 18.4 mm 23.0 mm 17.7 mm
Heel tab Finger loop Finger loop Finger loop
Midsole width - forefoot Average Wide Average
Midsole width - heel Average Very wide Average
Widths available Normal Normal Normal
Ranking Top 46% Bottom 27% Top 19%
Popularity Top 19% Top 28% Bottom 18%