Merrell Agility Peak 5 GTX
Pros
- True waterproof protection
- Grippy, trail-ready Vibram outsole
- Perfect for cold, wet climates
- Can handle some challenging conditions
- Stable yet cushioned heel
- Improved for hiking and walking
- Well-designed outsole lugs
- Great build quality
- Keeps feet warm
- Rock plate
Cons
- Narrow toebox
- Heel padding durability concerns
- No reflective elements
- Drop differs too much from stated
Key Features
- GORE-TEX waterproof membrane provides exceptional breathability and waterproof performance.
- Breathable engineered mesh and TPU upper for enhanced comfort.
- 100% recycled laces support sustainability efforts.
- Zipper closure for easy on and off access.
Specifications
- Sole material: Rubber
- Outer material: Engineered Mesh, TPU
- Inner material: Mesh
- Closure type: Pull-On
Merrell’s Agility Peak 5 GTX is designed for winter running enthusiasts seeking protection and comfort against icy conditions. Our lab tests confirmed that this shoe effectively safeguards against typical elements encountered during cold-weather runs, including slippery surfaces and discomfort. It features a notable Vibram outsole that provides excellent grip among snow running shoes.
The Vibram outsole demonstrated reliable traction during testing, equipped with deep 4.4 mm chevron lugs that enhance grip on slick ice. These lugs are thoughtfully spaced to manage both soft ground and more challenging terrains. This design instills confidence while navigating difficult winter conditions.
The upper is constructed with a waterproof GTX membrane, effectively blocking moisture and cold winds. Testing revealed minimal airflow in the dense upper, resulting in a ventilation score of 1/5, making it ideal for winter. As a result, we experienced no cold feet during our sub-zero temperature runs.
In terms of cushioning, the midsole is generously padded, particularly the 37.3 mm heel that absorbs landing impact well. Our durometer test indicated a near-average 21.3 HA, ensuring a balanced and comfortable running experience. Additionally, the shoe includes a rock plate that protects against underfoot hazards.
However, the Agility Peak 5 GTX may not be suitable for individuals with wide feet, as the tapered toebox can feel constricting. This aspect may limit its appeal for those who prefer a more spacious fit.
On Cloudhorizon Waterproof
Pros
- Effective waterproofing
- Abundant cushioning and impact protection
- Lively and responsive ride
- Amazingly light for its stack and waterproofing
- Great as a city-to-trail shoe
- Good stability for moderate terrain
- Comfortable in-shoe feel
- True to size and fit
Cons
- Not for serious hiking
- Lacks durabiity for the price
Key Features
- Waterproof Construction: Keeps your feet dry in wet conditions.
- CloudTec Phase® Technology: Provides exceptional cushioning for all-day comfort.
- Lightweight Engineered Mesh Upper: Made from recycled polyester, offering flexibility and breathability.
- Helion Superfoam Midsole: Enhances responsiveness and energy return during hikes.
- Missiongrip Rubber Outsole: Ensures superior traction on various terrains.
- Sustainable Design: Approximately 32% of the shoe's materials are recycled content, including 85% recycled polyester.
Specifications
- Origin: Imported
- Sole Material: Rubber
- Outer Material: Rubber
- Inner Material: Polyester
The On Cloudhorizon Waterproof is an excellent choice for individuals seeking a reliable winter hiking shoe, particularly for city-to-trail adventures. It features a winterproof woven textile that effectively retains warmth and provides substantial cushioning, enhancing overall comfort during treks.
This model is designed to minimize breathability, which is beneficial in colder conditions. It effectively traps body heat inside while preventing cold air from entering, as indicated by its low ventilation score of 1/5.
The midsole incorporates generous cushioning and the unique CloudTec technology, which helps absorb ground impact. We recorded a significant stack height of 39.4/29.2 mm, with rear shock absorption measured at 126 SA, ensuring leg fatigue is minimized even after extended pavement use.
The Cloudhorizon Waterproof's construction weighs just 12.0 oz (339g), making it 10.8% lighter than the average hiking shoe, which contributes to a more comfortable experience. However, its price point of $190 is notably above average, being 33.8% higher than typical hiking footwear.
This higher cost may deter budget-conscious consumers who might want to consider more affordable alternatives.
Salomon Speedcross 6 GTX
Pros
- Fully functional Gore-Tex membrane
- Ample cushioning for long adventures
- Excels in challenging, technical terrain
- Rapidly sheds mud
- Agile and tenacious grip on twisted trails
- Remarkable durability
- Ideal for heel strikers
Cons
- Completely lacks breathability
- Midsole could feel overly firm for some
- Exceptionally heavy
- Narrow, snug-fitting toebox
Key Features
- Unparalleled grip for enhanced traction on various terrains.
- Precise and comfortable fit that adjusts well to your foot shape.
- Waterproof and breathable Gore-Tex membrane to keep your feet dry.
- Revamped upper design for improved durability and comfort.
- Quick-lace bungee closure system for a secure fit.
Specifications
- Origin: Imported
- Sole Material: Rubber
- Outer Material: Polyester
- Closure Type: Bungee
The Speedcross 6 GTX is a versatile hiking shoe best suited for individuals seeking lightweight waterproof protection and superior traction on challenging trails. Its design features an impermeable upper and a reliable grip, making it effective in harsh weather conditions while enhancing agility.
Weighing in at 11.5 oz (325g), the Speedcross 6 GTX is 14.5% lighter than the average hiking shoe, allowing for prolonged trekking without foot fatigue. This balance of lightness and protection sets it apart as a notable choice among Salomon hiking shoes.
The fully waterproof upper utilizes a Gore-Tex membrane with a lab-tested breathability score of 1/5. This combination ensures that water does not penetrate the upper, effectively keeping feet dry during encounters with puddles or rain.
With chevron-shaped lugs measured at 5.0 mm deep, this shoe provides exceptional traction, outperforming the average by 1.5 mm. It demonstrates strong performance on muddy terrain and steep inclines, contributing to stability during aggressive movement.
However, the midsole may not deliver the deep cushioning favored by some hikers, as it prioritizes ground feel and stability instead. This aspect could be a drawback for those who prefer a softer underfoot experience.