Merrell Moab 3 Mid GTX
Pros
- Best-in-class waterproofing
- Great stability for moderate hikes
- Supportive for all-day wear
- Comfortable step-in feel
- Excellent grip on hard terrain
- Secure lockdown
- Sturdy construction
Cons
- Moderate impact protection
- Mesh panels are easy to tear
- Not for mud or soft terrain
- Moderate impact protection
Key Features
- GORE-TEX waterproof membrane: Ensures your feet stay dry while providing outstanding breathability and waterproof performance.
- Pig suede leather and breathable mesh upper: Combines durability with ventilation for increased comfort during extended use.
- Kinetic Fit ADVANCED removable contoured footbed: Offers medium support with reinforced heel cushioning for optimal comfort.
- Super Rebound Compound midsole: Provides durable shock absorption, reducing torque and allowing for a smooth transition into the midfoot.
- Vibram TC5+ outsole: Delivers exceptional traction suitable for various outdoor multi-sport activities, specifically formulated for Merrell boots.
Specifications
- Origin: Imported
- Sole material: Rubber
- Shaft height: Ankle
- Outer material: Leather
The Merrell Moab 3 Mid GTX is an ideal choice for hiking enthusiasts seeking comfort and stability across various trail conditions. After extensive testing, this boot has proven to provide substantial protection while enhancing performance and endurance during hikes.
Equipped with a Vibram outsole featuring deep 5.0 mm lugs, the boot delivers excellent grip on submerged rocks and slippery logs. The Gore-Tex membrane ensures that no water penetrates the boot, even in deep water crossings, although it received a low score of 1/5 in breathability during testing.
The boot offers ample cushioning, effectively shielding against sharp objects underfoot with its firm 32.8 HA cushion, as measured by durometer. Thanks to the 24.6 HA Air Cushion technology, each step feels significantly softer than the durometer reading suggests.
Its rigid construction enhances stability by preventing ankle collapse, supported by a stiff shank in the midfoot that earned a high 4/5 in torsional rigidity testing. Despite its firmness, the midsole remains flexible, scoring 33.2% above average in our flexibility assessment.
While the Merrell Moab 3 Mid GTX boasts solid waterproofing, it may feel excessively warm in temperatures exceeding 70°F (20°C). As such, it is best suited for colder weather conditions.
Salomon Quest 4 GTX
Pros
- Exceptional durability
- Top-notch waterproofing
- Excellent underfoot protection
- Highly secure ankle support
- Fantastic stability
- Comfortable in-boot feel
- Effective grip on various terrain
- Fits as expected
Cons
- A bit heavy
- Gets very stiff in cold
Key Features
- Stable & Supportive Design: Offers exceptional support for backpacking.
- Smooth Ride: Engineered for comfort over extended hikes.
- Enhanced Support: Provides extra stability during tough terrains.
- GORE-TEX Feature: Keeps your feet dry in wet conditions.
Specifications
- Origin: Imported
- Sole Material: Rubber
- Outer Material: Leather
- Closure Type: Lace-Up
The Salomon Quest 4 GTX is an exceptional hiking boot designed for backpackers seeking significant support, durability, and protective cushioning during multi-day hikes on challenging terrain.
Upon lacing up the boot, we immediately experienced the support provided by Salomon’s integrated ADV-C 4D chassis stabilizer. In lab testing, the boot received a score of 5/5 for rigidity, indicating it is the most rigid option available. This rigidity ensures that even when navigating rocky alpine trails with a heavy pack, ankle twists are virtually impossible.
For durability, the Salomon Quest 4 GTX performed impressively in our tests. We utilized a Dremel on the toe box, heel, and outsole, and all areas exceeded our expectations. After 12 seconds at 5K RPM and a force of 3.2N, the solid rubber toe cap showed minimal wear, providing reassurance for protection against bumps and scrapes while hiking on rugged trails or during light scrambling.
The midsole boasts an average firmness rating of 27 HA, as measured by our durometer. With a stack height at the heel being 2 mm above average, ample firm material is available to protect the heels from sharp rocks, which is particularly beneficial for heel strikers.
With a weight of 23.4 oz (663g), the Salomon Quest 4 GTX is typical for a supportive backpacking boot but may be excessive for casual day hikers. For this reason, we do not recommend this boot for light hikers or those primarily engaging in day hikes.
Salewa Alp Trainer 2 Mid GTX
Pros
- Fantastic stability on challenging trails
- Extra strong grip on technical terrain
- Secure lockdown and ankle support
- Exceptional durability
- Excellent waterproofing
- Great underfoot protection
- Flexible collar is handy on descents
- Fit can be regulated with an insole
Cons
- Drop is twice as high as stated
- Collar lining lacks durability
Key Features
- Full Comfort for Long Mountain Days: The boot is engineered for dependable weather protection which performs well in diverse terrain and conditions.
- GORE-TEX Extended Comfort: Enjoy reliable waterproofing combined with enhanced breathability, ensuring a comfortable experience whether you're navigating through warm, wet, cold, or dry weather.
- Vibram Alpine Hiking Sole: The rubber outsole features sharp lugs and reinforced rubber at the toe and heel, providing extra traction on steep trails.
- Salewa-Specific Features: The steel-cabled 3F System ensures stability while the MFF+ Footbed and EVA midsole deliver supportive cushioning. The climbing lace-up design allows for a snug fit from heel to toe.
Specifications
- Best Use: Trekking
- Upper Material: GORE-TEX Extended Comfort, Suede (1.4-1.6mm), 3F System, Rubber Rand
- Lining: Cleansport NXT
- Footbed: MFF+
- Midsole: EVA
- Outsole: Vibram Alpine Hiking
- Drop: 8mm
- Weight: 19oz
- Fabric Type: Synthetic, Rubber
- Origin: Made in USA or Imported
- Sole Material: Synthetic
- Shaft Height: Ankle
The Salewa Alp Trainer 2 Mid GTX is an ideal choice for those seeking a dependable snow hiking boot designed for technical terrain. Our lab tests validate its robust construction, which features toothy lugs that firmly grip the ground, a winterproof upper, and a stable platform suitable for various surfaces.
Upon examination, we noted deep 5.2 mm lugs arranged in an aggressive tread pattern that effectively engages harsh terrains. The boot provides impressive braking power on inclines, ensuring steady footing. Additionally, the rubber material offers protection against sharp rocks and roots, demonstrating significant wear resistance with only a minor 0.6 mm dent recorded during our testing.
In adverse weather conditions, including sudden rain or temperature drops, the Gore-Tex Extended Comfort membrane keeps feet warm and dry. Our smoke test confirmed that airflow is effectively restricted, earning this boot a low 1/5 breathability rating. This feature is vital for maintaining comfort during extended hikes.
The exceptional support of the boot allows for high-mileage hikes on challenging paths, preventing muscle fatigue. Its stiff internal shank ensures twist-proof stability, as verified by a 5/5 torsional rigidity score. Coupled with strong ankle support, it significantly reduces the risk of losing balance.
However, the Salewa Alp Trainer 2 Mid GTX weighs 19.2 oz (542g), making it somewhat cumbersome for those who prioritize maneuverability in their footwear choices. Hikers seeking a lighter and more agile option may want to consider alternatives.
Asolo Fugitive GTX
Pros
- Great grip on mixed terrain
- Fantastic underfoot protection
- Worth the price
- Waterproof
- Reliably supportive
- Feels light on the foot
- Zero break-in
- Balance preserver
Cons
- Outsole started peeling off
- Not-so-cushy footbed
Key Features
- Vibram Outsole: Ensures superior grip on various terrains, enhancing stability during your hikes.
- GORE-TEX® Lining: Provides water resistance while allowing breathability, keeping your feet dry in wet conditions.
- Lightweight Design: Ideal for trekkers who prefer a boot that doesn’t weigh them down.
- Duo Asoflex Midsole: Combines a stiffer material for anti-pronation and torsion with a softer one for shock absorption.
- Durable Uppers: Constructed from a blend of water-resistant suede and Cordura® for enhanced durability.
Specifications
- Fabric Type: 100% Leather
- Origin: Imported
- Sole Material: Rubber
- Shaft Height: 5.75 Inches
The Asolo Fugitive GTX is a winter hiking boot designed for those seeking support and stability in challenging conditions. Its watertight, protective upper and firm cushioning provide reliable defense against the elements while ensuring notable steadiness on snow-covered surfaces.
Equipped with water-repellant and heat-preserving construction, the boot effectively keeps feet warm and dry during winter excursions, allowing for uninterrupted training. The tightly woven mesh upper significantly limits airflow, as demonstrated in our breathability test. Additional safety features include rubberized toe bumpers, a suede upper, and a fully gusseted tongue.
The firm cushioning enhances balance on rocky and uneven terrains, while the stacked heel protects against sharp objects. This is complemented by a modest forefoot that facilitates some ground feel, contributing to overall stability. Our bend test revealed that it is an impressive 97.2% stiffer than average, which helps prevent awkward foot movements.
Grip is crucial for icy routes, and the Fugitive GTX excels in this area with its strong traction and 3.6 mm uniquely shaped lugs that ensure stability on slick surfaces. While the outsole rubber demonstrates durability, there is a notable concern regarding the adhesion to the midsole, as we observed peeling after only a few test hikes.
La Sportiva Ultra Raptor II Mid GTX
Pros
- Unbelievably lightweight
- Excellent waterproofing
- Doesn't let debris and falling rain/snow inside
- Exceptionally robust and durable
- Phenomenal grip on technical terrain
- Not so stiff and firm in low temperature
- Sufficient impact protection
- Highly supportive collar
- Ample flexibility
Cons
- Narrow platform
- Not for wide feet
Key Features
- Light & Fast Hiker: Engineered for those who prefer a boot that offers substantial protection while maintaining a lightweight feel, suitable for light to medium loads with an influence from trail running.
- GORE-TEX Waterproof Protection: Equipped with a Gore-Tex lining that ensures your feet remain dry and breathable even in wet conditions. A microfiber mud guard adds extra defense against trail debris.
- Sizing & Fit: Note that the Ultra Raptor II runs small. If you have normal or large feet, consider buying one size up. For smaller feet, a half size increase is recommended. Available in Regular (D) and Wide (E) widths.
- Sure Grip: The Frixion XT 2.0 Outsole features an Impact Brake System which provides superior traction and stability, making it ideal for steep descents and slick surfaces. An anti-shock rubber toe cap protects your toes from trail hazards.
- Ankle Support: The comfort collar enhances ankle protection, complemented by a reinforced heel cup that provides stability, especially useful during high mileage hikes on rugged terrain.
Specifications
- Sole Material: Rubber
- Outer Material: Rubber
- Closure Type: Lace-Up
- Water Resistance Level: Water Resistant
The La Sportiva Ultra Raptor II Mid GTX is a reliable choice for hikers seeking agility and support. It provides confident footing while maintaining a lightweight feel, making it ideal for those who prefer a boot-like hiking shoe.
Weighing only 14.6 oz (415g), this model is 21.8% lighter than average. Its low and loose design allows for enhanced maneuverability, particularly beneficial during scrambling or navigating technical trail sections.
With a high degree of flexibility, this boot feels weightless on the foot. In our bend test, it demonstrated 14.6% more pliability than average, ensuring comfort even during relaxed walks.
Despite its lightweight construction, it remains supportive with robust resistance against ankle twists and excessive lateral movements. Our manual assessment confirmed that it achieved a maximum 5/5 torsional rigidity score, indicating its strength under twisting forces.
A drawback of the streamlined design is the limited toebox room, which may hinder free toe splaying. We recommend individuals with broader feet consider opting for a more accommodating boot.