Topo Phantom 3
Pros
- Spacious, foot-shaped toebox
- Good versatility as a daily trainer
- Ideal for high-volume feet
- Lightweight
- Premium Ortholite insole
- Well suited for midfoot and forefoot strikers
- Comfortable for walking too
- Stable ride
Cons
- Needs a better foam
- Firmer feel
- Not for narrow feet
Key Features
- High-Cushion Design: These shoes offer ample cushioning to support your feet during lengthy runs.
- Zipfoam Midsole: The proprietary Zipfoam material provides a softer, lighter, and more responsive ride than traditional EVA.
- Breathable Upper: Made from recycled engineered mesh, the upper enhances airflow while ensuring a secure fit.
- 5MM Heel-to-Toe Drop: This design promotes natural running with optimal under-heel cushioning.
Specifications
- Fabric Type: Synthetic-and-rubber
- Origin: Made in the USA or Imported
- Sole Material: Ethylene Vinyl Acetate (EVA)
- Outer Material: Ethylene Vinyl Acetate (EVA)
The Topo Phantom 3 is designed for individuals seeking a wide toebox walking shoe, offering an exceptionally accommodating fit in both width and height. Its spacious design facilitates a fluid yet stable ride, as verified by our lab testing results.
Featuring a rounded silhouette, the Phantom 3 boasts a generous 82.1 mm big toe area, making it 11.4% wider than average and suitable for those with broad feet. Additionally, it provides a significant vertical clearance of 29.2 mm compared to the 27.1 mm average, ensuring comfort for users with high-volume toes.
The platform instills confidence with each step taken, supported by a dual-layer foam construction that includes a balanced 19.7 HA top layer and a denser 24.7 HA bottom layer for enhanced stability. This design contributes to an overall secure walking experience.
Moreover, the shoe's flexible build enhances its comfort; during our bend test, it demonstrated a 19.6% increase in adaptability compared to average, requiring less effort to move naturally while wearing it.
However, the upper construction could benefit from enhancements. It received a low score of 2/5 in our durability test and a moderate 3/5 for breathability, indicating areas for improvement.
Topo Atmos
Pros
- Max-cushioned comfort
- Ultra-spacious toebox
- Stable ride
- Premium Ortholite footbed
- Midfoot-friendly geometry
- Lightweight for its huge size
- Great for easy long runs
- No heel slippage
Cons
- Lacks energy return
- Not for narrow-footed runners
- Could be a bit more flexible
Key Features
- Max Cushioning: With a 40 x 35 mm platform, these neutral road running shoes offer exceptional plush comfort and shock absorption.
- Energetic Ride: The updated ZipFoam midsole provides lightweight cushioning and enhanced rebound, ensuring an efficient stride.
- Lighter Outsole: A newly designed outsole enhances grip and slip resistance while minimizing weight, allowing for a stable ride.
- Breathable Recycled Upper: Made from recycled materials, the engineered mesh upper offers excellent airflow and adaptability, promoting sustainability.
- All-Day Comfort: The OrthoLite Performance Insole delivers cushioned support that resists compression, suitable for extended wear.
Specifications
- Origin: Imported
- Sole Material: Rubber
- Outer Material: Polyester
- Closure Type: Lace-Up
The Topo Atmos is a wide walking shoe best suited for those seeking significant stability and comfort during extended walks. Our lab tests indicate that it provides exceptional impact protection while maintaining a well-balanced feel.
During testing, we noted the roominess of the shoe, with our caliper measurements revealing a base width of 119.1/96.8 mm. This is considerably wider than the average width of 114.1/90.6 mm, which contributed to a confident stance and solid footing with each step. Additionally, our gel mold replica indicates that the ball of the foot measures 98.5 mm, approximately 3.1% above average.
The Topo Atmos features a stack height of 37.8/32.5 mm and utilizes 20.0 HA cushioning, designed to dampen impact and deliver comfort without sacrificing support. Despite its substantial build, this model weighs only 9.7 oz (275g), ensuring it remains lightweight even after prolonged use.
However, it is important to note that the Topo Atmos exhibits a slightly stiffer construction compared to other options, which may be less suitable for individuals who prefer more flexibility in their footwear.
Adidas Supernova Rise 2
Pros
- Lighter than version 1
- Comfortable yet breathable upper
- Cold-proof PEBA midsole
- Stable ride with Support Rods
- Reflective accents for night visibility
- Maintains competitive price tag
- Responsive Dreamstrike+ foam
- Flexible, natural running experience
- Great for walking
Cons
- Outsole lacks Continental
- Not cushioned for forefoot strikers
- Still lacks a gusseted tongue
Key Features
- Supportive Design: The shoes incorporate a well-cushioned midsole that provides excellent support during runs.
- Durable Construction: Made with high-quality materials, they promise longevity even under rigorous use.
- Lace-Up Closure: The traditional lace-up design ensures a secure fit throughout your run.
- Versatile Use: Suitable for running, walking, and casual outings, making them a great addition to any wardrobe.
- Breathable Material: The polyester outer material allows for airflow, helping to keep your feet cool and dry.
- Reliable Traction: Equipped with a rubber sole that offers good grip on various surfaces, enhancing stability and safety.
Specifications
- Origin: Imported
- Sole material: Rubber
- Outer material: Polyester
- Closure type: Lace-Up
The Adidas Supernova Rise 2 is a highly spacious and supportive running shoe, making it particularly well-suited for individuals with wide feet. During our testing, both on the road and in the lab, this shoe demonstrated a forgiving ride that allows for extended mileage, especially among heel-strike runners.
This model provides ample space for broader or swollen feet, with our gel mold measuring the ball of the foot area at 98.7 mm, surpassing the average of 95.5 mm. Throughout our testing, there was no discomfort or unwanted pressure experienced on the feet.
Stability is enhanced by small side wraps in the heel and the Support Rods, which assist in aligning foot placement without sacrificing comfort. Our durometer measurements revealed a solid balance, with a reading of 21.0 HA, consistent with the average performance metrics.
The light and flexible construction contributes to an effortless sensation during runs. With a weight of only 9.1 oz (257g), it is below the average of 9.4 oz (267g). Additionally, the shoe exhibited 37.4% greater flexibility than average during our flex test.
However, we noted potential concerns regarding the outsole's durability, suggesting that those prioritizing longevity in their footwear may want to explore other options.
Hoka Gaviota 5
Pros
- Remarkably stable
- Breathable and comfortable upper
- Lightweight for its size
- Good stability option for forefoot strikers
- Ideal for wide feet
- Excellent for long runs
Cons
- Low drop might pose issues for heel strikers
- Performs poorly in colder conditions
- Not for narrow feet
- Midsole feels flat
Key Features
- Stability Support: Engineered to offer maximum support for overpronators.
- Cushioning: Advanced cushioning technology reduces impact during runs.
- Breathable Mesh Upper: Keeps your feet cool and comfortable even during long runs.
- Durable Outsole: Made from synthetic rubber for enhanced traction and durability.
- Wide Fit: Specifically designed to accommodate wider foot shapes for added comfort.
Specifications
- Fabric Type: Synthetic-and-rubber
- Origin: Made in the USA or Imported
- Sole Material: Synthetic Rubber
- Outer Material: Mesh
The Hoka Gaviota 5 is a highly recommended stability wide walking shoe, ideal for individuals seeking reliable support, ample dimensions, and notable comfort during walks. Lab tests indicate that its spacious base, H-Frame, and dual-density midsole significantly enhance surefootedness.
We measured the midsole at 125.1/106.6 mm, surpassing the average of 114.1/90.6 mm. This additional space contributes to secure footing, while the rigid H-Frame helps maintain proper alignment and stability.
The midsole delivers a pleasant experience with a plush feel that maintains structural integrity. Our durometer assessment reveals a dual-density configuration: a soft 12.9 HA primary cushion for comfort and a firmer 22.0 HA layer in key areas, promoting both support and durability.
The upper provides a refreshing fit and measures 99.7 mm at the widest part of the toebox, which is 4.4% larger than average, making it suitable for wider or swollen feet. Breathability is excellent, as demonstrated by a perfect score of 5/5 in our smoke test, allowing for effective temperature regulation.
However, it's important to note that the Gaviota 5 is 36.5% stiffer than average, which may detract from the light and natural feel preferred by some users.
KEEN WK400
Pros
- Rocker sole propels you forward
- Copious amount of cushioning
- Amazingly comfortable step-in feel
- Highly durable and abrasion-resistant
- More stable than it seems!
- Can go from road to trail
- Accommodating toebox
Cons
- Needs some getting used to
- Heavier than average
- Slippery when wet
Key Features
- MATERIAL & CONSCIOUSLY CREATED: Crafted with premium nubuck leather and breathable mesh lining to keep your feet cool.
- CLOSURE & COMFORT: Features offset lacing that reduces pressure on the top of the foot, along with a removable footbed for long-lasting comfort.
- TRACTION: Higher traction rubber offers sure footing, while multi-directional lugs enhance grip on stable terrain.
- SUPPORT & DESIGN: Incorporates a full-length featherweight nylon plate for added stability and KEEN.CURVE design for nonstop propulsion.
- FIT & CARE TIPS: KEEN Contoured Fit that adapts to the natural shape of your foot. Easy to care for by gently brushing with a damp sponge.
Specifications
- Sole material: Rubber
- Outer material: Leather
- Inner material: Mesh
- Closure type: Lace-Up
The KEEN WK400 is designed for individuals seeking a comfortable walking shoe specifically suited for wide feet. It provides a notable rocker experience, making it an excellent choice for those who prioritize smooth transitions while walking.
Featuring KEEN.CURVE technology and ultra-thick cushioning, lab tests demonstrate that the WK400 delivers exceptional comfort and ample space in all areas. The rockered bottom encourages forward movement whenever landing on the heels and is supported by a stiff full-length nylon plate.
With a stack height of 45.7 mm in the heel, the WK400 boasts deep and plush cushioning. Our durometer testing shows that the foam is 16.7% softer than average, contributing to a pain-free experience during extended wear.
This shoe excels in width, with our caliper measuring an above-average midsole width of 115.5/97.0 mm in the forefoot and heel. Additionally, the toebox measures 98.7 mm, which is 4.4 mm wider than average, accommodating those with broader or swollen feet comfortably.
However, a drawback of the WK400 is its difficulty in maintaining stability when standing still; it is optimized for movement. Individuals seeking a more stable shoe for stationary use may want to consider different options.
Allbirds Tree Dasher 2
Pros
- Comfortable and breathable upper
- Constructed with sustainable materials
- Carbon neutral
- Significant enhancements over v1
- Provides a stable ride
- Suitable for walking and gym training
- Excellent lockdown
- Spacious enough for really wide feet
Cons
- Might be excessively firm
- Overly spacious for those with narrow feet
- Pricey considering its performance
Key Features
- All-Day Comfort: Exceptional cushioning supports long hours on your feet.
- Sizing Tip: Recommended to size up by half a size; full size for wider fits.
- Breathable & Lightweight: Made with tree fiber, enhances airflow for cool, dry feet.
- Stability & Support: Durable outsole and cushioned crash pad absorb impact.
- Machine Washable: Easy cleaning by simply tossing them in the washing machine.
Specifications
- Origin: Imported
- Sole Material: Ethylene Vinyl Acetate, Rubber
- Outer Material: Tencel Lyocell
- Inner Material: Wool
The Allbirds Tree Dasher 2 is an excellent choice for individuals seeking a versatile wide walking shoe. It performed admirably during daily commutes and gym sessions, demonstrating remarkable flexibility that allows it to adapt seamlessly to foot movement.
Lab results indicate that the Tree Dasher 2 is **30.6%** more flexible than average, making it suitable for various activities. Its torsional flexibility resulted in a low rigidity score of **2/5**, allowing easy twisting without compromising stability.
The shoe provides a secure feeling with its firm base, confirmed by a high durometer reading of **27.0 HA**. Additionally, it offers generous space, enhancing control, with a measured width of **99.7 mm**, which is **4.4%** wider than average.
Comfort is further enhanced by its plush and breathable knit upper, which achieved a maximum breathability rating of **5/5** in our smoke test. The durability of the toebox is also commendable, earning a **5/5** score, a rare achievement in our testing environment.
However, while the upper shows significant durability, the outsole may not be as resilient. Those prioritizing longevity in their footwear should consider options with a more robust outsole.
Xero Shoes HFS II
Pros
- Anatomical toebox for natural toe splay
- Real minimalist design
- Reasonably priced
- Versatile for roads and light trails
- Amazing at gym workouts
- Ultra-flexible and easy to pack
- Full-length outsole coverage
- Superior ground feel
- Promotes feet strength
Cons
- Midsole lacks energy return
- Heavier than most minimalist shoes
- Durability still needs improvements
Key Features
-
Natural Movement Design: Emphasizes barefoot and minimalist principles with a wide toe box for natural splay.
Lightweight Performance: Weighing only 8.3 oz (Men's size 9), this shoe is designed for performance on the road.
Supportive Fit: Features a breathable mesh upper with moisture-wicking lining that keeps your feet dry.
Added Protection: Utilizes welded overlays for durability and an internal tensioning strap system to ensure a secure fit.
Durable Traction: Equipped with dual chevron lugs to provide excellent grip on various surfaces.
Specifications
-
Origin: Imported
Sole Material: Rubber
Outer Material: Textile & synthetic
Inner Material: Mesh
The Xero Shoes HFS II is among the best options for those seeking a wide-toebox walking shoe that provides a minimalist barefoot experience. It is particularly suited for individuals who prefer a light and unobtrusive footwear option while navigating urban environments.
Lab tests reveal that the HFS II is designed with minimalism in mind, featuring a weight of 8.6 oz (244g), which is 7.9% lighter than average. This lightweight feel is further enhanced by its highly flexible midsole, requiring 62.6% less force than average to achieve a specific angle, showcasing its free-flowing nature.
With a minimal stack height of only 13.1/12.1 mm between the foot and ground, the shoe significantly magnifies ground feel, in contrast to the average of 34.2/25.6 mm. Additionally, the 1.0 mm low heel drop contributes to a more natural ride.
The shoe's spacious toebox further adds to its comfort, allowing for a relaxed fit as it barely tapers towards the big toe area, measuring 86.7 mm, which is considerably more generous than the 78.4 mm average.
However, due to the thin cushioning, users may find that there is minimal bounce during use. Those looking for additional spring in their steps may want to explore alternative options.