ASICS Gel NYC
Pros
- Incredibly breathable
- Very comfortable
- Supportive and stable
- Features GEL techonology
- Fits true to size
- Feels light on foot
- Great mix of style and function
- Super trendy retro runner vibes
- Excellent grip even on wet
Cons
- Not durable
- Not for running
Key Features
- Upper construction inspired by the GEL-NIMBUS 3 and MC-PLUS V shoes
- Utilizes GEL-CUMULUS 16 tooling for enhanced performance
- Rearfoot and forefoot GEL technology promotes comfort in daily use
- Lightweight foam composition for better durability and feel
Specifications
- Material: Inner consists of Gel
- Available Size: 4.5
- Colorway: Graphite Grey/Black
The ASICS Gel NYC is best suited for individuals with flat feet who require stable and dependable support during their activities. Extensive wear tests, along with laboratory validation, confirm its robust structure characterized by a firm, wide, and rigid base. This sneaker stands out as a top choice for those with flat-footed needs.
The platform of the Gel NYC combines comfort with confidence, as evidenced by a durometer reading of 37.0 HA, indicating that the foam is 27.1% firmer and more stable than average. The midsole incorporates Gel technology in the heel, providing effective impact dampening alongside a welcome touch of softness.
The upper is made from a combination of genuine suede and leather, which helps keep the foot securely centered. The use of rigid materials and a chunky base enhances the shoe's construction to resist ankle twists, reflected in its high torsional rigidity score of 4/5 in lab tests. Additionally, the heel counter shares this stiffness rating, contributing to stability during movement.
The wide base measures 114.6/91.6 mm, offering a well-planted sensation that reduces the risk of losing balance, especially when compared to the average sneaker platform of 108.5/83.6 mm. This design feature supports aggressive movement without compromising stability.
However, it is important to note that the Gel NYC did not perform well in our durability tests. For individuals looking for sneakers that can withstand daily wear and tear, this model may not be the ideal choice.
Nike Air Max 270
Pros
- All-day comfort
- Fun and springy ride
- Incredibly lightweight
- Flexible structure
- Practical booty-like construction
- Perfect for active people
- Cool Nike Air technology
- Trendy futuristic vibe
Cons
- Upper lacks durability
- Not for people with wide feet
- Can be slippery on wet
Key Features
- Rubber Sole: Provides durability and traction for active play.
- Mesh and Rubber Upper: Offers breathability and a lightweight feel.
- Lace-Up Closure: Ensures a secure fit for all-day wear.
Specifications
- Sole Material: Rubber
- Outer Material: Mesh, Rubber
- Closure Type: Lace-Up
The Air Max 270 is a notable choice for those seeking a lightweight, stylish sneaker designed primarily for lifestyle use. With its towering stack height and distinctive exposed air bubble, this shoe represents a significant advancement in the Air Max lineup as the first model to be entirely dedicated to lifestyle wear.
Featuring a heel height of 36.4 mm, the AM270 establishes its presence in the chunky footwear category. It offers 21.6% stronger shock absorption than average, ensuring comfort during extended city adventures without feeling bottom-heavy.
Weighing in at 23.5% less than the average sneaker, the AM270's flexibility contributes to a weightless experience. Our bend test reveals it is 27.5% more malleable than standard options, allowing it to easily adapt to natural foot movements.
Constructed from breathable mesh, the AM270 effectively keeps feet cool and comfortable throughout the day. The inner lining is soft, and the well-ventilated design ensures a sweat-free environment, achieving a breathability score of 5/5 in our lab tests.
A potential drawback is that the upper material lacks wear resistance, as demonstrated by our Dremel test. If durability is a key concern for you, it may be worthwhile to explore other alternatives.
ASICS Gel Kayano 14
Pros
- Very stable overall
- Comfortable for all-day use
- Incredibly breathable
- Pretty lightweight
- Great lockdown feel
- Features Gel technology cushioning
- Retro-futuristic style
- Trendy Y2K vibes
- Great grip on wet and dry surfaces
Cons
- Not the most durable
- Not affordable
Key Features
- Original inspired tooling: A design that reflects the classic GEL-KAYANO style.
- 2000s design language: Nostalgic elements combined with contemporary flair.
- GEL Technology: Provides excellent shock absorption, enhancing comfort during runs.
- Solution Dye Sockliner: Manufactured using a process that reduces water usage by 33% and carbon emissions by approximately 45%.
- Trusstic System technology: Reduces the weight of the sole unit while retaining structural integrity, ensuring durability without adding bulk.
Specifications
- Sole material: Rubber for enhanced traction and durability.
- Outer material: Multi-textured materials for a unique look and feel.
- Inner material: Combination of leather, mesh, and synthetic materials for comfort and breathability.
- Closure type: Lace-Up for a customizable fit.
The ASICS Gel Kayano 14 is designed for individuals with flat feet seeking premium comfort and support. It features Gel cushioning, a flexible midsole, and a well-ventilated upper, making it suitable for various activities.
Our lab tests indicate that the Gel Kayano 14 is the most breathable option among flat-feet sneakers. The numerous ventilation holes allowed for maximum airflow during our wear tests, earning it a perfect 5/5 breathability score.
Beneath the foot, the balanced 30.0 HA midsole provides stability, supported by a wide 113.3/88.2 mm base. This design contributes to a stable walking experience without the need for constant adjustment of foot placement.
To enhance comfort, the shoe includes a plush 25.0 HA Gel cushioning in the heel, promoting softer landings. Despite its width, the Gel Kayano 14 remains agile, weighing only 12.4 oz (352g), which is 9.7% below average, thus reducing the potential for early fatigue.
The shoe also exhibits minimal resistance to bending, appearing slightly more flexible than average. However, during testing, we found that the upper material was prone to tearing, indicating that those prioritizing breathability over durability may want to consider alternative options.
New Balance 990 v6
Pros
- Unexpectedly lighter than average
- Real suede and quality materials
- Extra thick cushioning for all-day wear
- Mind-blowing arch support and stability
- Exceptionally hard-wearing outsole
- Fantastic breathability
- Well-padded all around
- Six(!) widths available
Cons
- Very delicate toebox mesh
- A bit stiff
Key Features
- FuelCell foam delivers a propulsive feel to help drive you forward.
- ENCAP midsole cushioning combines lightweight foam with a durable polyurethane rim for all-day support.
- Crafted with a suede and mesh upper for breathability and style.
- Lace-up closure ensures a secure and customizable fit.
- Modernized version of the iconic 990 silhouette adds a contemporary touch to a classic design.
Specifications
- Origin: Made in the USA
- Sole material: Rubber
- Outer material: Mesh
- Inner material: Cotton
The New Balance 990 v6 is designed for individuals seeking retro aesthetics combined with exceptional support and luxurious comfort during walks. This sneaker incorporates technologies from earlier models, such as the FuelCell midsole and the ENCAP rim, which provide significant arch support. Among footwear options for flat feet, it stands out as a notable choice.
The FuelCell cushioning offers plush protection, featuring a generous stack height of 39.1/23.8 mm. The foam's quality contributes to gentler landings, as evidenced by its high 102 SA rating in our shock absorption test.
Stability is enhanced by the wide base measuring 113.8/88.0 mm, with the ENCAP rim ensuring secure heel placement. Its balance is remarkable, reflected in a high 5/5 torsional rigidity rating obtained during our manual twist test.
The upper of the sneaker is made from real suede, confirmed through our torch test, and provides ample ventilation for comfort during extended wear, particularly in hot weather. Our lab tests indicated maximum breathability, demonstrated by easy smoke flow, resulting in a 5/5 score.
However, this focus on comfort and stability leads to a drawback: flexibility. Bending the feet requires more effort compared to other sneakers, which may be a concern for some users. If flexibility is a primary need, exploring alternative options may be advisable.
Nike Initiator
Pros
- Great impact protection for all-day wear
- Fairly stable and supportive
- Lightweight structure
- Pretty durable overall
- Super breathable
- Cool 2000s retro-futuristic vibe
- Great traction (waffle sole)
Cons
- Not for running
- Runs small for some
Key Features
- Comfortable hold providing stability on all routes
- Breathable upper material that enhances ventilation
- Soft, padded design for increased comfort during wear
- Supportive overlays that help center the foot in the shoe
- Soft lining that contributes to overall wearing comfort
- Foam midsole offering a cushioned feel underfoot
The Nike Initiator is designed for individuals seeking a comfortable running shoe that provides notable support, making it suitable for those with plantar fasciitis. Lab tests demonstrate its firm and stiff midsole, which works in tandem with a flexible forefoot and lightweight construction. This sneaker has been verified as one of the best lightweight options for plantar fasciitis based on our testing.
From the first wear, we found the Initiator remarkably comfortable, weighing just 11.6 oz (329g), which is 15.9% lighter than the average sneaker. Its flexible midsole enhances the weightless feeling, facilitating ease of movement. In our bend test, it showed a 6.9% increase in adaptability compared to the average performance.
The midsole offers additional support for the heels, featuring an extra 2.7 mm of foam in the rear versus the average sneaker. The high drop of 12.7 mm further alleviates pressure on the feet. Stability is confirmed by our durometer readings, showcasing a high measurement of 31.4 HA.
The Initiator incorporates a top lateral wall that enhances stability during movement. In our torsional rigidity test, it received a score of 4/5, indicating effective resistance against twisting, which contributes to a more centered ride while worn.
It is important to note that the Initiator tends to run smaller than standard sizing. We recommend considering a size up for optimal comfort and fit.
New Balance 327
Pros
- Fashionably sporty
- Excellent impact protection
- Stable and planted platform
- Lightweight and comfortable
- Above average breathability
- Excellent grip
- Suitable for driving
- Budget-friendly
Cons
- Not suitable for wide feet
- Not as supportive as other NB sneakers
Key Features
- Design Inspiration: A reimagining of 1970s running shoes, combining vintage aesthetics with modern technology.
- Asymmetrical Branding: Unique 'N' logo placement adds a creative touch to the overall design.
- Trail-Inspired Outsole: Offers excellent traction and stability for various terrains.
- Materials: Crafted from synthetic materials and leather, ensuring durability and comfort.
- Closure Type: Features a traditional lace-up design for a secure fit.
Specifications
- Origin: Made in the USA or Imported
- Sole Material: Synthetic Rubber
- Outer Material: Synthetic
- Closure Type: Lace-Up
The New Balance 327 is a sneaker that offers notable ventilation and luxurious comfort at an affordable price point of $90, making it a recommended choice for those seeking breathable footwear.
During our assessment, we verified the upper's porosity by shining a light on it. The numerous vent openings around the quarter and toe box became evident when smoke continuously flowed during our smoke test.
Weighing in at 10.62 oz (301g), the 327 is lightweight, being 35.2% lighter than most tested sneakers. However, this model may not be suitable for individuals with broader feet, as our measurements indicated a maximum toebox width of 94 mm, which is 4 mm below the standard width. For wide-footed wearers, opting for sneakers that provide more room in the toe area may be advisable.
Reebok Classic Leather
Pros
- Mighty plush
- Great investment
- Leader of the pack
- Supportive
- Aesthetically well-rounded
- Enduring
- Affordable
Cons
- Downgraded upper
- Dirt-magnet
Key Features
- Soft Leather Upper: Made from high-quality leather, providing comfort and durability.
- Minimalist Design: A clean look that works well with multiple styles.
- High Abrasion Resistant Rubber Outsole: Ensures stability and traction during wear.
- Cushioned EVA Midsole: Offers all-day comfort and support.
- Wide Size Range: Available in sizes 7-14 to accommodate different foot sizes.
Specifications
- Origin: Imported
- Sole Material: Rubber
- Outer Material: Leather
- Closure Type: Lace-Up
The Reebok Classic Leather is an ideal choice for individuals with flat feet, combining a classic design with substantial support. Its robust construction is complemented by a lightweight structure, making it comfortable for extended wear. Lab tests confirm its stable platform, affirming its position as our top classic sneaker for this foot type.
This sneaker originates from the Reebok Classic collection and has historical ties to running shoes. The design features a well-cushioned stack measuring 35.7/22.1 mm, providing notable impact protection during activities. Our durometer readings show a firmness score of 35.1 HA, which is 20.6% above average, resulting in a securely planted feel.
The leather material contributes to minimal flexibility, as evidenced by our manual assessments that indicated difficulty in twisting the shoe and pinching the heel counter. Both features received a high rigidity score of 4/5, ensuring a secure foothold while walking. This rigidity enhances stability but may not suit all preferences.
Despite its sturdy build, the Reebok Classic Leather is surprisingly lightweight, weighing only 11.4 oz (323g), which is 17.2% lighter than average. This streamlined construction aids in comfort; however, it may not be suitable for those with wide feet or bunions due to its less accommodating fit. Overall, while there are advantages, potential users should consider these limitations before purchase.